Kay`s Pizza in Averill Park

We just move to the area from Brooklyn to a cabin and had no idea we would find our selves in the most magical pizza spot we have ever been to. The Pizza was out of this world, the view is phenomenal and somehow the service is even better!! Will be back all the time.

It was great as usual 😊 Kay's doesn't disappoint. First experience was 1961. What a great system. Pizza and staff was and still is the best.

Best pizza around!! We moved away for a few years and really missed NY pizza. Kay's filled that void. Really going to miss it when we leave. But until then, we will keep ordering.

Greatest pizza ever.... Love the outside dining...

Still has great pizza. Very good and fast friendly service. Ate outside, service people all wore face masks. Very happy with both food and service.

Absolutely fabulous! Delicious! Great service! Antipasto was excellent! Pizza was a culinary delight!

Good food and friendly service, clean establishment and pretty quick at get the orders filled and out the door !! I always recommend them to my friends and family when they ask where to get good food or a nice place to eat !! I just moved up this way so I haven't gotten the chance to eat a meal and look out at the lake I bet it pretty nice ! But yeah I give Kay's a 👍🏼 two thumbs up👍🏼 !!!!!

The best pizza you'll have in your life

It was good. Nice place on the lake. Pizza was good, NOT NYC OR LONG ISLAND GOOD, that would be asking for way too much!,,, but if you want a tasty Pizza in a nice location it's a good scene.

The pizza was wonderful as usual. The waitress could of been a little happier. We tipped her generously hoping she has a better day.

Also known as Kay's Pizza, this is one of my absolutely favorite summertime places to eat! With a really cool 1950 feel, the atmosphere on Burden lake is hard to find elsewhere. Kay's is known for their pan style pizzas but what isn't as well known is that they have some of the best crispy wings around! But hurry in, they are only open in the summer months!

We enjoyed the food the first time we went, even though we waited on hold for over 10 minutes, went to pick up an hour later and still waited another 20 minutes. But very understandable in these trying times. What wasn’t understandable was being on hold for 32 minutes today and finally hanging up. There’s not even enough people in this town to have 32 minutes worth of orders ahead of me! It takes about a minute to place an order for a pick up, so I can’t imagine how I possibly could have waited 32 minutes. The food was good and we were lookin forward to trying it again, but I’m not sure we will.